I was reading over this press release by the NDP today, and I am lost as to what the heck Layton is even trying to accomplish with it. Especially this quote:
“That’s why I’m announcing that as a first step, New Democrats are calling for the withdrawal of Canadian troops from the combat mission in southern Afghanistan. Withdrawal should begin as soon as possible - working with our international partners to ensure a safe and smooth transition - but with a view to having it complete by February 2007.
Canada can then focus on building a made-in-Canada foreign policy that moves us toward reclaiming Canada’s place in the world. One that is clear, comprehensive, and balanced.”
To me this seems like the absolute worst thing to do, just as the Conservative’s plan to pull out of Kyoto and build a “made-in-Canada” environmental policy is a bad idea. The argument behind this is that the current strategy is not working so we should stop everything and rethink it and then implement a new strategy entirely, but when it comes to war (or most real world problems) this is just plain absurd. As it would be absurd if a dyke was leaking and your initial strategy was to put your finger in the holes you see to keep the water from flooding everywhere, and then you realized that strategy doesn’t work, so instead of coming up with a new strategy and transitioning to it after you have come up with it (ie. trying to get filling plaster to fill the holes so they don’t leak anymore and you can stop more holes while still holding the ones you have blocked up) you take your fingers out of the holes, let the place flood while you try to think up a new “made-in-canada” strategy to deal with the problem.
We are in Afghanistan, and pulling out without any plan other than to pull out is going to cause a lot more trouble there than it is going to help. However, trying to resolve the situation so we are not dealing with a civil war/counter-insurgency problem and remaining there until the new solution is implemented is the best way to deal with the problem. There is a very huge list of problems with the Afghanistan situation, however I do not believe that packing up and leaving is really going to make matters much better. Especially if you leave without some form of reasonable exit plan, all you are going to create is a power-vacuum.
We can debate the ins and outs of whether or not being in Afghanistan is good for Canada until we are blue in the face. The problem is that we are there, and now we need to do our best to resolve the situation without causing more problems. Leaving so suddenly does not seem like the best way to do it, and that press release definitely did not convince me otherwise.
If Layton can present me with a reasonable exit plan that will provide a way for Afghanis to deal with the current crisis in their country on their own and allow Canadians to leave without causing more problems, then I will agree with it. But just telling me that the troops should be back in Canada by some arbitrary deadline is not going to help. I understand the desire to bring them home, but at the same time it needs to be done in a rational and safe manner.
…..1337hax0r…..